Legal Roundup: What We Know About Lawsuits Council Discussed in a Closed-Door Meeting
The East Lansing City Council had a special meeting Nov. 10, spending almost the entire four-hour session in a closed-door meeting with attorneys to discuss collective bargaining and pending lawsuits.
The litigation discussed involves a police officer accused of causing a car crash while on duty, a dispute over the future cost of a downtown land lease, a developer challenging the City Council’s rejection of an apartment complex and two men who say they were wrongfully arrested and subjected to excessive force by police.
East Lansing Info dug through court records to get the latest on the litigation the council discussed.
Harrison v. City of East Lansing, East Lansing Police Department, and Logan Wainman
This lawsuit was filed by Noel Harrison, who was injured after getting in a car accident with an East Lansing Police Department cruiser in April of 2024, according to filings at Ingham County’s 30th Circuit Court.
According to filings, Harrison was driving north on Abbot Road near Lake Lansing Road. Harrison merged into the left hand turn lane when ELPD Officer Logan Wainman, who was traveling in the same direction, saw a speeding driver and began to make a U-turn without turning on emergency lights or signaling, crashing into Harrison’s car.

According to Harrison’s attorneys, the collision caused spinal injuries that prevented her from sitting for long periods of time and living a normal life.
In this litigation, East Lansing is represented by Giamarco, Mullins and Horton, the firm that held the city attorney contract at the time the litigation was filed. Attorney Anne Gabbert argued at a Feb. 25 hearing that Wainman’s actions did not meet the threshold of “gross negligence” and questioned the severity of Harrison’s injuries.
While Harrison had healed by the time attorneys presented information in front of Circuit Court Judge Rosemarie Aquilina at the Feb. 25 hearing, the judge still saw the injuries as having an impact and said there is evidence Wainman was at fault for the accident.
“She [Wainman] also admitted fault for the collision, as well as while I understand the defendants are arguing maybe negligence but not gross negligence, that is a question for the jury,” Aquilina said according to a transcript. “And gross negligence is defined as conduct so reckless as to demonstrate substantial lack of concern for whether an injury results, and I think a reasonable jury could make that conclusion.”
There was a trial set for March 6, however, the city filed an appeal with the Michigan Appellate Court regarding government immunity and at the Feb. 25 hearing, Aquilina said that trial was adjourned to let the appeal play out.
The appeal was dismissed in September, according to the Michigan Appellate court’s website.
TDP Acquisitions, LLC v. City of East Lansing
This litigation was initiated in August, shortly after the East Lansing City Council rejected a 10-story apartment complex proposed by Tareen Development Partners, or TDP, where the Bailey Street surface parking lot currently sits.
As ELi previously reported, TDP is asking an Ingham County 30th Circuit Court judge to overturn the council’s decision, writing in an appeal that the city’s site plan review was unnecessary and broke the law. TDP’s attorneys argued that the proposed development met the city’s zoning standards and therefore would only need to receive a building permit.
The City Council rejected the apartment at a July 21 meeting, citing concerns about the proposal’s compatibility with nearby properties, parking and traffic congestion. The council also raised concerns about a heating and cooling system planned for the project that city staff members said could harm an important aquifer, however, developers offered to drop this portion of the project at the July meeting. In a court filing, TDP’s attorneys called the decision to reject the apartment “arbitrary and capricious.”

Along with asking the court to overturn the council’s decision and allow the development to proceed, TDP is asking for attorney fees and other costs incurred during the appeals process, according to filings.
While the litigation is still in early stages, more recent filings show that the City Council’s approval of “The Howard” will be part of TDP’s argument. The Howard is a 12-story apartment being constructed downtown that was approved at the same meeting TDP’s project was rejected.
Along with asking for notes and other materials related to the council’s decision to reject TDP’s apartment, the developer’s attorneys are asking for materials related to the approval of The Howard.
In its most recent filing, submitted Nov. 10, the city asked the court to limit the record to materials considered by the City Council at its July 21 meeting and the development’s site plan. City attorneys argued that documents related to The Howard and minutes from city board and commission meetings should be excluded because they were not part of the council’s decision.
University Place Condominium Associates v. City of East Lansing
For 40 years, University Place Associates Condominium Association has leased the property that hosts the Marriott Hotel, a parking garage and several businesses for just $10 per year, developing the land and building the parking garage in exchange for the minuscule rate.
In April, ELi reported that University Place is suing East Lansing over a dispute about the terms of its future lease, including how much it will pay. The city has countersued. The litigation is pending in Ingham County Circuit Court.
The original agreement stipulated University Place could renew its lease in 10-year increments for annual payments equal to 12% of the land value, which could push the $10 lease payments to more than $500,000 annually. Now, there is a disagreement about the new lease amount.

In 2019, the city and University Place each had the land assessed, with the city’s assessment finding a value of $4.1 million and University Place’s assessment finding a value of $3.1 million. With the wide disparity in valuations, a third assessment was done.
The third assessment valued the property at $4.5 million. The city claims that the value of the land would be determined by taking the average of the third valuation and the assessment closest to it, a methodology city attorneys say University Place participated in implementing. This would make the value about $4.35 million and annual payments about $520,000.
However, University Place lawyers argue in filings that the Marriott Hotel’s lender, Huntington National Bank, was not involved in the assessment process. Lawyers say Huntington had to be included according to an estoppel agreement the city and Marriott entered in 2016.
The city has accused University Place of “stringing [it] along” for years and disputing a land appraisal process it participated in, filing a countersuit.
The latest filings, entered to the Circuit Court on May 19, show the value of the land is still being contested.
Smith and Woods v. City of East Lansing et al
This litigation was filed in the U.S. Western District Court of Michigan in Grand Rapids and has gained significant attention over the last year.
In August of 2025, during Michigan State University’s Welcome Weekend, an ELPD officer pepper-sprayed two young Black men downtown. The department issued a press release about violence downtown that singled the two men pepper-sprayed out by name, Lonnie Smith and Mason Woods, stating that they were arrested for charges related to fighting.
However, the attorney for both men, Jack Rucker, later released security footage from a business that appears to show Smith stepped in to deescalate an altercation between his friend Woods and other men in line outside of a restaurant. After the footage was made public, city attorneys dropped charges against both men.
It was extremely unusual for the city to include the names of individuals accused of misdemeanors in a press release. A series of records requests by East Lansing Info showed that prior to the press release’s publication, the city’s communications consultants believed they were to include another individual arrested for unrelated reasons because he shares a last name with Smith’s mother, Nadia Sellers. For weeks prior to the press release’s publication, Sellers had been speaking critically about the police department at city meetings.
Despite substantial public interest, city officials have declined to comment on the incident for more than a year, saying that speaking on the matter could jeopardize the city’s insurance coverage.
In an email to ELi, Rucker said there has been little recent movement in the case, with about 15 depositions scheduled for December and January. He added that he hopes to see progress on discovery requests after filing a motion to compel last month.
