The Priest and the Police Officer
Melissa Congleton spends her Sundays at the pulpit, clerical collar affixed and Bible in hand.
She spends her Mondays in a police cruiser, badge on the front of her uniform and service weapon on her hip.
Earlier this month, the 50-year-old marked her 28th year as a police officer with the Michigan State University Department of Public Safety.
For Congleton, the two professions aren’t contradictory. Instead, she sees them as complementary ways of serving others, rooted in a belief that every person deserves dignity, compassion and grace.
Congleton grew up Catholic in Midland, Michigan, but her relationship with organized religion became complicated during her teenage years.
“I came out as a lesbian when I was a teenager,” she said, “and I started falling away from the church at that time, because I just didn’t feel that church was compatible for me. I’m not meaning to throw the Catholic Church under the bus by any stretch of the imagination. I think they do a lot of good things. I think each person has to find a church community that resonates with them. And I try not to get too wrapped up in labels and faith traditions — if it’s a fit for [you] and [you’re] doing good things, that’s a win in my book.”
Congleton said there have been times when she stepped away from the church, but she never lost her faith. She ended up joining the Episcopal Church.
By high school, she knew she wanted to become a police officer, viewing law enforcement as an opportunity to give back to the community.
In her late 20s, however, she began feeling another calling: the priesthood.
Initially, she brushed it aside. She had begun a successful career in law enforcement and didn’t feel the need to pursue something else. Perhaps, she thought, the priesthood could wait until retirement.
“[But] I just felt the call get stronger and stronger until I had to do something about it,” she said. “So I took one step down that journey of pursuing ordination, and it led to the next step, and the next step, on a long road.”
Her supervisors supported her decision to attend seminary, asking that she also train to become a chaplain for the MSU Police Department.
Over nearly three decades, Congleton’s law enforcement career has included patrol, community policing, emergency management and a stint as the homeland security officer for the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams. Now, toward the end of her career, she’s returned to patrol, a role she said she’s enjoying.
“Service has been something that’s come naturally to me my whole life,” she said. “Over time, I’ve come to see service as more than just doing a job well. It’s about helping safeguard people and the community and doing so with justice and compassion and humility. And to try to get all those together is right. It’s a challenge in this day and age.”
Her theology, she said, is grounded in the belief that every person has inherent dignity as someone loved by God.
“Our baptismal covenant, which says we’ll respect the dignity of every human being … this is something I really do strive for every day, regardless of what job I’m at,” Congleton said.
She strives to be the same person whether she’s wearing a clerical collar or a police uniform. Humility, mercy and hope, she said, are qualities that transcend both professions.
That philosophy shapes how she approaches situations in which enforcing the law might not be the most compassionate response.
Congleton offered the example of encountering an unhoused person while walking through one of the wooded areas on MSU’s campus.
“I walk in the woodlots a lot on campus,” she said. “If I come upon an unhoused person urinating in public in the woodland area; is it a crime? Absolutely. Could I cite them? You bet. But that isn’t helping the unhoused person who can’t pay for the citation and doesn’t have a home. It just gives them one more burden. If they don’t take care of the ticket, they get a warrant. It just creates a snowball of more problems for a person who’s already carrying a heavy load of challenging things.
“There’s times when an arrest can be made and a person can be cited. Yet, taking into account human dignity, an arrest might not be the best option.”
She makes a conscious effort to remind herself that everyone she encounters is carrying burdens that might not be visible. Whenever possible, she tries to extend grace and mercy.
Congleton said each officer brings different strengths to the job, and she values working alongside colleagues whose approaches differ from her own.
“I bring what I have to the call and my colleague will bring what they have,” she said. “Honestly, I prefer to work with colleagues who have skills vastly different than me because we balance each other out. If my partner is having an interaction with a person and it’s going well, I’m gonna let it roll because I don’t need to interject. It could cause a problem or make the situation worse. But if my partner’s trying one tactic that doesn’t work, I can jump in with a different one that’ll keep that [situation from] escalating.”
For Congleton, policing has taught her how to respond to people in crisis, while her faith has helped her understand why being present matters.
She calls this the “ministry of presence,” describing it as the clearest overlap between her two careers. In both roles, she’s encountered people on some of the worst days of their lives and learned the importance of remaining calm, steady and compassionate.
“My faith keeps me grounded in the belief that people are more than their actions,” she said. “We don’t want to be judged on our worst day and because of that, I’ve been able to be more patient and more measured and more humane, I think, as an officer.”
That perspective also informs her work as a chaplain for MSU Police, where she supports fellow officers and professional staff.
Congleton said ministering to her colleagues is different from supporting parishioners at St. Katherine’s Episcopal Church, a rural parish with fewer than 100 worshippers that draws congregants from surrounding communities, including Haslett.
Her fellow officers know she’s spent nearly three decades working alongside them, sharing many of the same experiences and challenges.
“That creates a connection like no other,” she said. “We have a trust.”
More than anything, Congleton said, being a police chaplain means listening and being present. Her role isn’t necessarily to solve problems. In a challenging world, she said, people often simply need someone willing to hear them.
Her faith tradition also encourages her to ask difficult questions, challenge her own beliefs and recognize that she doesn’t have all the answers.
“My faith tells me that every person is created in the image of God, even though all of us fall short,” she said. “Both policing and ministry have taught me to take sin seriously, but never to give up on people. I don’t believe anyone is inherently bad. I do believe people can make bad decisions and have bad actions, yet that doesn’t lead me to say a person is a bad person.”
Over her nearly three decades in law enforcement, Congleton has watched public attitudes toward police ebb and flow.
She has seen periods of intense scrutiny, including the aftermath of George Floyd’s murder by a Minneapolis police officer, which sparked protests across the country. She’s also experienced moments of public support, including the aftermath of the Feb. 13 MSU campus shooting.
Congleton said she can often gauge how people feel about her profession simply by reading their body language.
“I’ve seen the tide turn to where the police are more popular and looked at as a friend and helpful,” she said. “Kids will come up to you at Spartan Stadium and thank you for your service.”
Despite the differences between her professions, Congleton doesn’t believe they are fundamentally at odds.
Asked whether her careers ever contradict one another, she paused for several seconds before answering.
There are moments of tension, she said, but not contradictions.
“Law enforcement is about accountability, order, and protecting the community,” she said. “Clergy are called to proclaim grace and forgiveness and the possibility of redemption. In a well-functioning society, I think these things need each other.
“Accountability matters because our actions have real consequences, and grace matters because no person should be reduced to the worst thing they’ve done.”
The two professions sometimes require different approaches.
In policing, Congleton said, she often must address a problem immediately, even if the solution is temporary. During a domestic violence call, for example, that might mean separating the parties or making an arrest.
Ministry, on the other hand, often requires more listening, patience and time before taking action.
“In policing,” she said, “we have to respect the limits of the law and the department standards and ethical considerations.”
For Congleton, both professions ultimately return to the same guiding principles: serving others, respecting human dignity and recognizing the possibility of redemption.
Someday, she said, she’ll put down her gun and badge and devote herself entirely to ministry.
She’s not sure when that day will come, but she’s been told she’ll know when it’s time.
